Sample Critical Review: ‘Turkle’ LEARNING AND ACADEMIC SKILLS RESOURCES 1. Have a look at the assignment question left 2. Now read the sample review. Read the accompanying comments on the side as you go. Is this is a well written review in your opinion? At the beginning of a review the last year, a number of poor papers have been submitted to the journal. Papers submitted to the journal are now reviewed using one of four check-lists, which are designed to evaluate papers that report either a research study or a review of the lit-erature or a systematic review or a case report. Instructions to authors and all four check Table of Contents Page 1 Abstract 3 2 Introduction 4 3 The Problem 4 4 Literature Review 4 PEST Model 5 SWOT Model 5 The Evolutionary Cycle Model 5 The Six-Box Model 5 The 7S model. 6 5 The Critique 6 6 Effects of Change on HR 7 6 Effects of Technology on HR 8 7 Recommendations 8 1 Abstract Walt Disney is undergoing a Change in its busness model with the Author: Ivawolf
Free Essay: Critical Review of a Research Paper
We use cookies to give you the best experience possible. IntroductionA research paper is much like the mirror reflection of the research proceedings, where the researcher provides the fragments of the proceedings in such a manner that in the end it would remind one a completed jigsaw puzzle with each fragment is fitted in its appropriate compartment to provide a complete picture.
Therefore, a research paper stands to share its joy of discovery to its targeted readers, who would be able to associate the elements of the research to its purpose, would be convinced with the logistics presented and would be encouraged to carry the research forward.
Thus this research paper on critiquing others research work chooses the research paper presented by the trio, Kenneth J. Don't use plagiarized sources. Harris and David M. The Critical review of a research paper example Applied in CritiquingThe critiquing breaks down the paper into three segments — One, Problem definition, two, critical review of a research paper example design and data collection, and three, analysis and interpretation.
All segments thereafter have been divided into appropriate sections to create its own jigsaw towards finding the strengths and weaknesses of the paper and summarizes the same in its conclusion. Quality of BackgroundThe researches have chosen to arrive at the scene from the word go, as it briefs LMX Leader-Member Exchange theory in one breath, thereby completely overlooking the significance of presenting the issues embedded with LMX, like transactional leadership, specific nature of it and how LMX theory evolved under what conditions and why it is significant in the current context.
In the process it missed out the following points which are seemingly pertinent to create the very premise of understanding:LMX theory is an extension of transactional mode of leadership that appreciates transformational leadership, yet discards the labyrinthine process of it. It is the competitive atmosphere in the modern day business sector has given birth of LMX theory for the companies to gain most in shorter time and thereby maintaining a competitive advantage over other companies belonging to the same league.
How LMX is supposed to work by exploiting motivation-reward principles among the satellite group. The advent of globalization has converted the modern corporate world into a place for only fast paced, result driven companies who can make the most in shortest possible time — and from that perspective LMX is a significant contribution to modern management. It seems that the researchers have taken the readers for granted that they will be thoroughly conversant with the background of LMX and thus decided to start from the middle.
This paper thus lacks a quality background. That evokes questions like below, which remain answered in the research:What is the real problem that this research intends to serve? What is the significance of its finding and where it can lead to? The mere absence of huge research on a factor or two related to a theory cannot be a solid ground of research, unless that absence poses as problems.
Without a problem, a study turns into narration of observation, and unfortunately, this paper tows that line. Therefore, this can be opined that this paper does not possess a clearly defined problem, save highlighting its significance. Quality of the Literature ReviewThough the paper contains around 40 references, it seldom goes beyond quoting inferences from the earlier researchers, interspersed by general comments, seemingly attempting to bridge several ideas.
Here too the researchers are expected to touch down the reasons why such a relationship receives research attention or in which way LMX provides a useful framework or how it differs from other leadership theories.
This pattern of presentation is prevalent in most of literature review part and thus it goes on creating a long list of unanswered questions. If a fact is worth mentioning, then the reason behind it should also be mentioned. Alongside, the marshalling of facts should drive home the prime fact — the finding.
While such attempt can be found in this paper, the lack of explanation of the facts used blurs that attempt. Either research on antecedents does not merits attention2. Or critical review of a research paper example has gained significance under the modern day context.
That kind of elucidation requires extended research too, like the rise and fall of companies and the preconditions of survival amid the environment of globalization — that too is missing in this paper, which otherwise could have been instrumental to help the readers to see the forest among trees. These flaws in the literature review altogether diffuse the enthusiasm of the readers who are deprived of the vital clues associated with the research. This theory of Abraham Maslow [1] provides an outline of human needs that a manager should know and exploit to motivate the employees, because motivation is guided by unfulfilled needs.
Physiological Needs: Air, Water, Nourishment and Sleep — these are the critical review of a research paper example needs of humans and a company should take care that the employees are having all these in proper measure.
Safety Needs: This need covers the issues of safety in both living and in workplace, medical insurance, job security and financial backup. Company should try to contribute in all of these areas with the view that the problem in any of these areas takes away the focus of the employees. This provides much needed mental space and time to the employees, where they can afford to pursue another vital need like Social Need.
Social Needs: Group activities, socialization, or enhanced interpersonal communication are the elements that fulfill the social needs and which are well within the ambit of a company to imbibe in the employees, critical review of a research paper example, where they form a sense of belonging, which paves the way for the next need, that is Esteem Need.
This creates the platform to pursue the self-realization process, which is a unique and endless process, where one can bask in the endless discoveries about oneself. Maslow had named this ultimate need of humans as Self-actualization. There were other handy theories too, critical review of a research paper example, like ERG theory or Need Theory, which could have served as a perfect foil to the research issue.
Research Design and Data CollectionThis segment probes the merit of research design, methodology, sampling strategy and maintenance of ethical norms while treating the respondents. It encompasses a very large area of study and thus merits a sub section of research to convince the readers, critical review of a research paper example. Appropriate Critical review of a research paper example AppliedThere is nothing wrong with the methods applied, where it appears that the researchers have tried to maintain balance on certain elements of research like sex ratio, age range or job experience.
Therefore, it would have been better had the researchers opted for some other companies that involves in a full-scale production or at least doing their business in an intense competitive environment — because, it is the stress and strain of the situation that brings out the inner elements of humans to a great degree, and accordingly, the employees of a full-scale company here could have provided more richness and variation in their feedbacks regarding team communication, leader-member communication or personal life-view or global view.
Maintenance of Ethical NormsSimpler method was adopted in sampling where the researchers duly asked for the consents of the respondents that followed by a forwarding letter of the lottery company and a pen-and-paper survey, where everyone was assured of their anonymity, critical review of a research paper example.
It clearly appears that the researchers have maintained the required ethical norms while dealing with respondents. Analysis and Interpretation. Findings do Link with Research Objectives and Literature ReviewThe findings as placed on table 1 and table 2 do connect to the research objective and literature review, as they provide partial critical review of a research paper example full support to the hypotheses.
That aligns with the study goals as declared by the researchers too — as it examines the relationship between three subordinate personality variables and LMX quality besides examining antecedents and consequences of LMX quality in the critical review of a research paper example study, while investigating whether LMX mediates the personality-outcomes relationships to reach their findings.
Alignment between Conclusion and FindingsSince the issue critical review of a research paper example deals with intangible items like elements of human behavior, which is always dynamic, no finding can be complete and final in determining the outcome in every instance of the application of LMX training.
Admission of LimitationsConsidering the fact that there is a good many loose ends in this paper which the researchers have not addressed in any form, it can be said that they are not frank and thorough in presenting the limitations to research.
However, this can always happen in the situations where the researchers cannot identify the gray areas of their work, critical review of a research paper example. This in a way hints at their admission of limitations of this research. ConclusionThe discussion above clearly shows that this paper has more weaknesses than its strengths, as it starts with an observation and not with a problem directly related to LMX.
The paper has left many chinks in its literature review and subsequently limited the scope of the issue by selecting atypical samples to find answers for the situations that are more prevalent in the full-scale companies. Since there was no argument to defend or to win over, this paper ends up an extended observation, which might have some bearing on the future line of research, where its findings can serve a clue or two towards solving problems arising out of the practice of LMX.
Otherwise, this paper resembles a jigsaw that has a good many squares empty, in spite of successfully filling up some of its areas, thereby succeeding only presenting partial picture of the whole. Ends References Barnett, K. Dansereau, F.
Social Work Research, 25 1 : Gerstner, C. Journal of Applied Psychology, Graen, G. Leadership Quarterly, 6, Jung, D. and Avolio, B. Academy of Management Journal, 41 2 : Lussier, R, critical review of a research paper example. and Achua, C. Eagan, MN: Thomson-West. Manzoni, J. How Good Managers Cause Great People To Fail. Boston: Harvard Business School Press. Web document. Leadership Theory and Practice.
Sage Publications, Popper, K. Hutchinson Education. php [1] A devoted Social Scientist who researched extensively to create a workable pattern and placement of various human needs, where he traced clues in monkeys! Cite this A Critical Review of the Research Paper A Critical Review of the Research Paper. A Critical Review of the Research Paper. Accessed April 29, This is just a sample.
You can get your custom paper from our expert writers. All you need to do is fill out a short form and submit an order. Due to recent legislative introductions, the website is currently unavailable in Australia. We need some time to make sure our experts are fully compliant. We are doing our best to get back to you the shortest.
Stay tuned! See Pricing. What's Your Topic? Hire a Professional Writer Now. The input space is limited by symbols. What's Your Deadline? How Many Pages? Sign Up and See Pricing. Please enter valid email. Back Get Offer. Write my paper. Deadline: 2 days left.
Dr Dan Article Critique Assignment Example
, time: 9:04Essay Examples: Critical Review Assignment
Essay Examples - Critical Review Assignment. The research topic discussed concerns the existence of statistics anxiety among graduate students. One primary question is whether or not there is a prevalence of procrastination among such students. Research data reveals that approximately 80 percent of students experience higher than average IntroductionA research paper is much like the mirror reflection of the research proceedings, where the researcher provides the fragments of the proceedings in such a manner that in the end it would remind one a completed jigsaw puzzle with each fragment is fitted in its appropriate compartment to provide a complete picture Table of Contents Page 1 Abstract 3 2 Introduction 4 3 The Problem 4 4 Literature Review 4 PEST Model 5 SWOT Model 5 The Evolutionary Cycle Model 5 The Six-Box Model 5 The 7S model. 6 5 The Critique 6 6 Effects of Change on HR 7 6 Effects of Technology on HR 8 7 Recommendations 8 1 Abstract Walt Disney is undergoing a Change in its busness model with the Author: Ivawolf
No comments:
Post a Comment